Your Art, Your Terms: Why Artists and Makers Need a Home Base of Their Own
On December 16, Etsy’s new Terms of Use take effect. If you sell there, it’s a good time to ask who actually controls your work online.
Etsy updated its Terms of Use and Privacy Policy on October 26, and they take effect December 16. Most of the attention has gone to one line: Etsy and its “third party partners and vendors” may use your content “to develop, train, test and improve artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies.”
To be fair, the rest of the picture is less dramatic. You still own your work, and Etsy doesn’t claim otherwise. The license you grant Etsy was already perpetual, irrevocable, and sub-licensable. What’s new is that AI training is now explicitly named, and the opt-out the terms mention isn’t clearly available to US sellers. Closing your shop also doesn’t undo any of it.
Whether you think that’s a big deal or a small one, the lesson is the same. When your business lives on someone else’s platform, someone else writes the rules, and they can rewrite them. Etsy has changed its terms before and will again. So have Instagram, Pinterest, and every other platform where artists have built an audience.
What a home base looks like
A website of your own, on a domain you control, changes who holds the pen:
- You write the terms. Your site’s copyright notice, usage terms, and image policies are yours, and no Tuesday-morning email can change them.
- Your work lives where you put it. Your portfolio, your shop, and your story sit under your name instead of inside a marketplace’s index.
- Your audience is yours. A newsletter list can’t be taken away by an algorithm change or a terms update.
- You can leave, and so can your work. Your domain is registered in your name, and a WordPress or custom site can be moved to another host or developer without starting over. You’re never locked in, even if I’m the one looking after it.
What it doesn’t do
I’d rather be straight with you: a site of your own doesn’t make your work scrape-proof. Anything public on the web can be copied by someone determined, and the rules that stop bots (like robots.txt) are voluntary. What you can do is raise the bar:
- Block known AI crawlers at the server or CDN level, and say so in your terms.
- Publish web-sized images instead of full-resolution files.
- Add visible or embedded copyright and licensing information.
- Keep your highest-value work behind a purchase, a contact form, or a login.
None of that is a guarantee. All of it is more control than a marketplace license gives you.
Keep Etsy if it’s working
I’m not telling anyone to quit Etsy. It’s a real discovery channel, and plenty of makers get most of their sales there. The approach I’d suggest is to treat marketplaces as storefronts and your own site as home base. Post there, sell there, but make sure the portfolio, the email list, and the story of your work live somewhere you control.
How Two Bit can help
I build websites for artists, makers, and small creative businesses in Kansas City and beyond, by hand and without page-builder bloat. For this situation, that usually means:
- A portfolio and shop that look like you made them on purpose, built on WordPress or as a custom site
- Your choice of how it’s run: you can hold the domain and hosting accounts yourself, or I can take care of all of it for you. Either way, the domain is registered in your name.
- AI crawler blocking and image protection configured and documented
- A newsletter signup so your audience comes with you
Not sure who controls your domain, hosting, and email today? Who Actually Owns Your Website? walks through a twenty-minute check.
If you sell on Etsy and the December 16 changes made you uneasy, get in touch. We’ll look at what you have, what you’d want to own, and what a sensible first step looks like.
Sources: Etsy Terms of Use · Etsy Privacy Policy · Value Added Resource’s reporting